What Google and OpenAI Say


Short answer

How do you show up in AI answers?

Showing up in AI answers means an AI tool cites or links your page when it answers a question. Google says no special markup or AI files are needed: the page must be indexed and eligible for a search snippet. OpenAI’s search uses its own crawler. Nobody can guarantee a spot.

Ask an artificial intelligence (AI) tool for a good tax preparer nearby. It names three firms and links to their pages. The firm down the street is not one of them. This is an illustration, not a real case.

How did the tool pick? The companies that build these tools have published part of the answer. Here is what they say, what the click data shows, and what nobody can promise.

What does it mean to show up in AI answers?#

Showing up in AI answers means an AI tool names or links your page. It does this while answering someone’s question. The answer sits at the top of the screen, written in plain sentences. Your page appears beside it as a supporting link, one of several sources.

Marketers call the work behind this answer engine optimization (AEO). The name is new. The work is not.

Two such features run inside Google’s search, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Both show a written answer with links to supporting pages. OpenAI runs a search feature inside its chat tool that does the same.

Each answer is built for one question at a time. The same page can be cited for one question. It can be missed for the next one a person types.

Read Also:  The AI blind spot that nobody in the room will name · Hanh D. Brown

How do AI answers choose their sources?#

In the pages read here, neither company gives a full formula. Google describes one step, which it calls a “query fan-out.” Its system may run several related searches across subtopics, then writes a response for the person and shows supporting links. That is the most either page says about the selection itself.

That step explains a pattern people notice on the screen. An answer can cite a page that a plain search would not show on its first page. Google says its AI features can show a wider set of links than a classic search.

Not every search gets an answer at all. AI Overviews appear only when Google’s systems judge them useful, so they “often don’t trigger.” Many questions still get the old list of links.

Wording matters too. Pew Research Center, an independent research group, studied Google searches from March of last year. Just 8% of one- or two-word searches produced an AI summary. Searches of 10 words or more produced one 53% of the time.

Long searches got one about half the time. One- and two-word searches rarely did.

How the answer is assembled from many pages is a separate story. This site covered one version in an essay on AI agents at scale.

How do I get my website to show up in AI searches?#

Google’s answer is short: “There are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode.” To be eligible as a supporting link, a page must be indexed and allowed to show a snippet in regular search. A snippet is the short text under a search result. That is the whole technical bar.

Its guide for site owners was last updated in December of last year. It is just as plain about what you do not need. You need no new machine readable files and no AI text files. You need no special markup and no special structured data.

The guide lists ordinary habits instead:

  • Let crawlers in.
  • Link your own pages to each other.
  • Keep key facts in text.
  • Make page data match the page.

None of it is new. It is plain search work.

Read Also:  Will Human-AI Coevolution Extend Our Lifespans?

Being in the index is like having your number in the phone book. It does not make anyone call.

Site owners can also limit what appears. Google points to the same snippet controls it has long offered, such as a tag that tells it not to show a snippet. Tighter limits mean less of the page can appear in AI answers.

Software robots do the finding. They are called crawlers. A crawler visits a page, reads it and reports back. Each company runs its own, and they are asked to follow the instructions a site leaves for them. Block the right crawler and the site drops out of that company’s answers.

OpenAI publishes a list of its crawlers and what each one does. One is for search. Sites that block it “will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers,” the company says, though they can still appear as plain links.

A second crawler gathers pages that may be used to train its models. That one is separate. A site can allow the search crawler and block the training one.

A third agent visits a page only when a person’s request needs it. It never roams alone. OpenAI says robots.txt rules may not apply to it. A person sent it.

The setting lives in a small file on a website called robots.txt. A public internet standard describes it. Its rules are requests that crawlers are asked to honor, “not a form of access authorization.” A robots.txt file is like a sign on the gate, not a lock. Polite visitors stop. Others may not.

Changes to that file take time. OpenAI says about 24 hours for its search. That is one day. Google says a recrawl after a change to its preview controls can take from several days to several months. The two figures cover different changes. It is not a fair race.

Is AI killing website traffic?#

In one study, AI summaries came with fewer clicks on Google. Pew tracked the browsing of 900 adults in the United States in March of last year. The gap was large. It ran one way. It is one study of one month. Other samples could differ.

Share of Google search visits with a click on a regular result link, March of last year. Source: Pew Research Center.

Pew compared search pages with an AI summary against pages without one. When a page showed a summary, people clicked a regular result link on 8% of visits. Without a summary, they clicked on 15%, nearly twice as often. A link inside the summary itself got a click on just 1% of visits.

Read Also:  On writing like you genuinely mean every single word · Hanh D. Brown

People also ended their browsing more often. They ended their browsing after 26% of pages with a summary, against 16% without one.

Google adds a different point. It says clicks from pages with AI Overviews are “higher quality,” meaning people are more likely to spend more time on the site. It gave no number in that guide, and Pew did not measure time on site. The Pew short read gave several numbers on clicks.

Fewer clicks. Longer visits, maybe. Both can be true at once.

Can anyone guarantee a spot in AI answers?#

No. Google says so in writing. A page that meets every requirement may still not be crawled, indexed or shown, because “indexing and serving isn’t guaranteed.” The company that runs the answers will not promise a place in them. So no one selling a service can promise one either.

So a promise of a sure spot goes further than the company itself does. Treat it like any other claim, and check the claim first before you pay for it.

What does improve the odds is the same work as always. Google’s advice for its AI features stresses unique, useful content for people. That echoes a point made here before: when copying gets cheap, the value moves elsewhere.

Results get counted, too. Visits from AI features show up in the regular search reports of the Search Console tool, under the web search type.

A promise of first place is like a fishing guide who swears you will catch a fish. The guide controls the boat, not the fish.

Go back to the tax preparer down the street. Picture a family firm with one clear page that answers the question its clients ask most. That page will not be cited every day. But it can be read, it can be found, and it gives an AI tool something true to quote when the day comes.

Source: Google Search Central, AI features guide.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top